Donald Trump
Self (archive footage)
Mindy Robinson
Grace The Reporter
Dywayne Thomas
John Murphy
Lia Marie Johnson
(archive footage)
Shane Ryan-Reid
Brandon
Sabrina Culver
Stacy Miller
Ice Cool
Chad
Ken Holmes
Miguel 'Snakeskin' Perez
Cris Cochrane
Samael 'Sam' Dubhan
Leah Coonce
Karen
Barack Obama
Self (archive footage)
Josh Outzen
Ted Bundy Admirer
Gary Lee Vincent
Agent Walker
Mark Valeriano
Michael Lake
Jared Oakley
Marc Hockl
Sophia Cacciola
Kelly Thompson (segment: Cable 54 News - Why Do Killers Kill?)
Brandi Aguilar
Piper Lopez
Kelley Wilson Robinson
Roxie
Glenn Berggoetz
Bill Carl
Emily McKinley Hill
Jason Impey
Officer Joe Newton
Acadia Colan
Serena
Richard Chandler
Biker
Tony Newton
Navah Raphael
Parker Rhodes
Delaney Vallese
Victim's Sister
Steven Perillo
Interviewee
Rosann Ferrier
Jan Parsons - Criminal Psychology
Hunter Otto
Hunter Schmidt
Bryden Elliott DiGennaro
Victim's Friend
Derrick Gilbert
Young kid
Gant Montgomery
Officer Thompson
Urszula Makowska
Interviewee
Chuck Chapman
Johnny Starr
Thomas Gangstad
Crazy fan
Roberto Ragone
Detective Mark Agnello / President of Necrophiliacs Anonymous
Axle Gunn
Detective
Travis Lance Sosa
Robert
Josh Hayes
Dr. Ian Gensuse (segment "Sue")
Klaudia Lucia Wyzykiewicz
Actress
Val Tannuzzi
Alejandra Gomez
Nick Charles
Serial Killer Fan
Maude Michaud
Sara (segment "Made For You")
Dean Houlihan
Simon / Killer
Steve Mack
Brandons Nephew
O'Neil Thomas
Interviewee
Kevin Lapham
Det. Wilson Brown
Luc Bernier
Martin (segment "Made For You")
Chris Miller
Deranged Interviewer
Spencer Mathis
Roman Brion
V (Segment "Fear the Ghetto Killer")
Iris Crenshaw
Criminal Psychologist
Justine Colan
Cousin #2
Dena Navarroli
Michaela Lillestol
Lilith Singson
Suzana Trifkovic
Victim's Friend
Carly Richardson
Sam
Scott Geiter
Family Friend
Chris Pinto
Miles Thornbush
Rose Pendleton
Scott Bray
Tom Smith
Gino DiNardo
Connor Komoroski
Ted Bundy Fan
Petey Hixson
Killer in Van #2
Teresa Tuttle
Reid's mom
Robert Alesandro
Max Caulfield
Gregor Collins
Jeronomo Rozebush
Jeynelle Dean-Hayes
Sue Tralfero (segment "Sue")
Bradley Louis Kramer
Louie
Vincent Maeder
Ralph Witkins
Tom Culo
Doctor
Lluvia Almanza
Amanda Marie
Nancy Pinto
Annabelle Thornbush
Krister Twizz Forsberg
Victim
Judith Etzelstorfer
Witness
Vex X. Starskream
Perpetrator
Timothy Patrick O'Neill
Jimmy Champane
Mike (segment "Poetry in That")
Luke Y. Thompson
Jagger Trouant
Drew Holland
Jerry O' Nofre
Conspiracy Guy
Stefanie Slack
Girl in Van #2
Devin Williams
Jimmy
Eddie Forsberg
Young Brandon
Rhys Griffin
Adrian
Brenda Carey
Harper Bennet
Shelley Fairbanks
Zoey 'FreaqShow' Peterson
Holly Ruth Bailey
Karen
Pierce Bunch
James Hartley
Alan McLoughlin
Alan
Doug Christman
Branden Vives
Interviewee
Ralitsa Chobanova
Dean Michael Smith
J.R. Wilson
Dwight Cooke
Junior (segment "Cruel Yule")
Amish
Bella Farris
Victim's Sister
Larry McKenzie
Cheyanne Allison
Eric Cire
Dave (segment "Poetry in That")
Kirse Cosey
young Reid
Anthony Caligiuri
Enya d'Entremont
Cousin #1
Beatrix Victoria
Victim (segment "Cruel Yule")
Rachael Kim-Ainsworth
Reporter (voice)
Ashley Smith
Ashley
Carla Dawn d'Entremont
Cameron Patrick
Brandon Marc Powers
Owen Walsh
Abbie Williams
Ruby Collingwood
Tessa Hold
Saveaya Oz
Pearl
Eveline Dunlap
Jenna Renee
Victim
Samari Clark
Roe
Jean Joseph
Jean
Carl d'Entremont
Firsherman
Paolo Vanoli
Brandon Fan (segment "Brandon Lives")
Greg Boyea
Ron Stone
Jeremy Maury
Jeremy
Jennifer White
Aleksandra Brown
Girl in Van #1
Tina Matasari
Raped Girl (segment "Brandon Lives")
Michael Andrick
Amanda DaSilva
Garrett D. West
Danny Stevens
Corey Seaver
Peyton Prescott
Hunter Smith
Hunter
